News: Sensation!!! Prazosin Cyber pharmacy viagra Soma fm Tegretol Norflex Clofazimine Ambien Can woman take viagra Generic cialis india Phentermine in the uk Foscarnet Nicotrol Tessalon Flomax Phentermine addiction help Gentamicin Altace Dobutamine Xanax and grapefruit juice Viagra soft tabs Free viagra order online Tramadol used for Generic xanax photo Effects from side viagra Thiphenamil Imipramine Nexium Tolazamide Online viagra consultation Information viagra Phentermine cheapest Lethal dose xanax Alternatives to phentermine Phentermine 30 mg Encare Prednisone Cephapirin Hydrocodone vicodin Saturday delivery cheapest phentermine Methyclothiazide Quinapril Ciclopirox Famotidine Low price viagra Buy phentermine pay cod Online cialis Trientine Real phentermine Time released xanax Cheep tramadol paris france Cialis review Allopurinol Buspirone Phentermine diet pills cheap Tramadol dogs Mark martin viagra Alprazolam Viagra sample pack Marijuana On line vicodin Dovonex Phentermine mexico Brand drug generic name viagra Discount phentermine online Order xanax Acetophenazine Ethionamide Lactulose Phentermine cheap no prescription Hydrocodone cough Vytorin Viagra experiences Order viagra prescription Phentermine buy Order phentermine on line Which is better cialis or levitra Imodium Benztropine Cefpodoxime Macular degeneration caused by viagra Meperidine Buy levivia viagra Risperdal Cialis Does viagra woman Hexamethonium Cheapest xanax Substitute viagra Xanax cod Misoprostol Phentermine studies Terazosin Soma seed Phentermine Phenytoin Asparaginase Albendazole Hydrocodone apap 5 500 Phentermine prescriptions online physiphen online Methscopolamine Buy Cialis Dulcolax Phentermine warning Doxepin Phentermine pill online discount Cheap phentermine online 37 5 Cheap overnight phentermine Mail order viagra online Niaspan Diet discount phentermine pill Buy viagra canada Viagra premature Ultracet Xanax on line Hydrocodone addiction Cialis story 120 cheap tramadol Pindolol Ssri phentermine heart Cheap phentermine with online consultation Phentermine 37.5mg tablets Motrin Viagra female sexual inhancement Fill viagra prescription Vicodin overdose Cheap tramadol no prescription Approval cialis Xanax 1mg Imuran Anisotropine Cialis free sample Buy phentermine with no prescription Carteolol Moxifloxacin Viagra online uk Xanax withdrawel Capoten Buy cheap phentermine yellow Cheapest viagra on line Viagra pictures 10 min viagra Buy cialis generic Phentermine no rx Cheap viagra online Meridia diet pill Dolasetron Buy meridia Mepenzolate Cheapest cialis Phentermine priority mail Soma financial Xanax abuse Discount hydrocodone Pal pay phentermine Glipizide Cheap phentermine diet pills Viagra online shop Viagra substitutes Viagra dosages Alprazolam xanax over night Cialis online Cheapest viagra prices Lexapro Tramadol hci Idarubicin Xanax indications Maprotiline Buy xanax without prescription Buspirone Cheapest viagra online Xanax withdrawl Aurothioglucose Adderall skin allegra skin xanax skin Online ordering viagra Pfizer xanax Hydroxyurea Cialis and pomegranate interaction Ethinyl Free sample viagra Estrace Chinese viagra dragon power Trihexyphenidyl Line prescription viagra Phentermine & health risks Cialis drug for impotence Fast acting viagra Dicumarol Methylergonovine Grapefruit xanax Free phentermine sample Oxytetracycline Glucotrol Cheapest secure delivery cialis uk Diprolene Ativan re valium vs vs xanax Cheap prices phentermine Phentermine 15 mgs Online pharmacy and phentermine Non perscription viagra Viagra supplier Generic viagra from india Side effects of xanax Phentermine cod Streptokinase Xanax xr Buying viagra online Different types of phentermine Long term effects of xanax Buy cialis viagra Imodium Filing income tax buy tramadol What happens when women take viagra Xanax pics Ipodate Cialis experiences Side effects of viagra Adipex Lowest prices on phentermine Viagrafix corporation Norepinephrine Does viagra work for women Phentermine Hytrin Diet phentermine Lose weight with phentermine and 5 htp Arava Viagra generic brand Discount viagra online Buy online prescription viagra without Xanax picture Side effect of viagra Viagra pulmonary hypertension Uk viagra sales Order soma Phentermine delivered overnight Phentermine insulin Accolate Mepindolol Thyrotropin Herbal viagra for woman Clofibrate Phentermine for sale Viagra prescription uk Buy phentermine online no prescription Amiloride Adipex diet phentermine pill Xanax alcohol Phentermine order Viagra energy drink Nizoral Phentermine next day delivery Dicyclomine Methazolamide Link buy online viagra info domain Chlortrimeton Canada xanax Nadolol Lowest price for phentermine Does xanax show up on drug tests Generic price viagra L arginine natural viagra Buy phentermine by cod Viagra lowest price Tranylcypromine Phentermine ephedrine Cimetidine Tramadol long term use Metoprolol Viagra advertisement Uk viagra body building from sports supplement Buy cheap no phentermine prescription Discount phentermine no prescription Coumadin Glyburide Diet pill addiction phentermine Norvasc Phentermine free delivery Side effects of xanax xr Verapamil Cheapest phentermine price How long does phentermine stay in your system Meridia vs phentermine Climara Dalteparin Loxapine Chemical name for viagra Phentermine side effects danger Viagra commercials Generic fioricet Cheapest xanax online Oxazepam Generic sample viagra Diet drug loss phentermine weight What is phentermine Carbamazepine Mexican pharmacies online+no precription xanax Xanax detox Online pharmacy prescription viagra Online viagra prescriptions Phentermine caffeine Where to buy viagra on line Viagra high blood pressure Xanax side effects Iodothyrin Ramipril Xanax suicide Discount viagra sales Adipex phentermine prescription Losartan Viagra alternative Antazoline Canadian viagra Phendimetrazine versus phentermine Phenacetin Ways to inject xanax pills Grapefruit viagra Generic cialis softtabs Herbal viagra Meridia Phentermine 37.5mg Adipex phentermine weight loss Viagra prescription drug Phentermine no rx needed Drug screen xanax Singulair Cefmetazole Buy cheap domain online atspace com xanax Dangers of viagra Sofia viagra Cialis effective soft tab treatment Nitroprusside Soma online Nortriptyline Meridia Drug information picture identification tramadol er bvf Phentermine 37 5mg Glucotrol Foradil Cialis comparison levitra Viagra and high blood pressure Lowest phentermine 37 5 prices Best price on phentermine Order generic cialis Viagra patent infringement reexam Levofloxacin Mometasone Viagra uses What does phentermine look like Order viagra now Buy xanax online Buy cheap online uk viagra Phentermine on sale Phentermine information Paxil Xanax effects Dihydrotachysterol Vicodin abuse Viagra use Information loss phentermine weight Erythrityl Discount phentermine Lisinopril versus viagra Accupril Hydrocodone prescription online Drug vicodin Fda approved phentermine Arava Using viagra Buy cheapest online viagra Tramadol hcl Chloroquine Compare viagra price Spironolactone Phentermine free shipping 90 supply no delay Diflunisal Flonase Order phentermine online uk Viagra alternate Compare viagra to cialis Buy cheapest online place viagra Tramadol 180 Cialis drug interactions Compare viagra prices Non prescription phentermine Canada cheap viagra Phentermine shipped to florida Divalproex Anxiety disorder xanax xr to wean off effexor xr Cialis pills How long xanax stays in system Mitoxantrone Amitriptyline Levivia vs viagra Ionamin Viagra levivia alternatives Fluconazole Aciphex Xanax effect Actos phentermine aciphex imitrex Lanoxin Cheap perscription phentermine Phentermine hcl Spiramycin Xanax in pregnancy Lanoxin Riboflavin Viagra mexico Bumetanide Phentermine medication Cialis levivia viagra compare Hydrocortisone Vicodin withdrawal symptom Buy online pharmacy viagra Levitra vs cialis Viagra sale uk Vitamin b12 1000 mcg phentermine and panic attacks Meridia vs. Phentermine Nitroglycerin and viagra Digoxin Lowest viagra price Viagra without a perscription Cialis drug impotence Clonazepam Addiction tramadol Phentermine rx Buy cialis soft tabs Uk viagra suppliers Drug phentermine 37.5 pdr Viagra cheap Fioricet line Liqued viagra Viagra and pulmonary hypertension Isotretinoin Generic viagra online Phentermine work Cialis western open Viagra conviaindications Tramadol hydrochloride Cheap phentermine 37.5 mg diet pills Phentermine message board Lasix Phentermine versus meridia Imiquimod Minipress Moxalactam Pyrazinamide Ecstasy Plaquenil Side effects of tramadol hydrochloride Protirelin 50 mg tramadol Cialis price compare Buy cheap tramadol Fexofenadine History of phentermine use Lexapro Overnight xanax or alprazolam delivery Flovent Cialis com Phentermine affordable Monopril Nimodipine Ceclor Buy Xenical Cinoxacin Chlorambucil Azathioprine Hydrocodone information Lasix Viagra maker Buy viagra online cheap Nasacort aciphex phentermine actos imitrex Herbal phentermine side effects Fluticasone India generic viagra Methadone xanax interaction Butalbital Drug laws ohio diet phentermine Skelaxin Mephentermine Hexoprenaline Cialis side effects Buy no phentermine prescription Erection viagra Buy Carisoprodol Best viagra prices online Tramadol 100mg Kevin harvick viagra Purchase tramadol Discount drug viagra Order soma online Female viagra Luvox Generic viagra pill What is viagra Lamivudine Prinivil Generic cialis prices Pediacare Methamphetamine Indomethacin Cardura Flurazepam Phentermine online without a prescription Phentermine and sibutramine be combined Tramadol abuse Best online deal for phentermine Xanax withdrawl symptoms Phentermine 6 pm order Penicillamine Xanax prescriptions online Discount tramadol 30mg phentermine Zyprexa Dichlorphenamide Liquid cialis Cheap cialis Discount fioricet Captopril Naproxen Cefixime Buy cod online phentermine Phentermine gynecomastia Phentermine usa Nicotrol Amikacin Viagra overnight delivery Methadone and xanax Better than viagra Phentermine 30mg cap Leflunomide Claritin Cheap phentermine without a prescription Proguanil Buy viagra in canada Adipex p phentermine Cheap phentermine online no prescription Elocon Lawsuits involving blindness caused by viagra Viagra cialis levivia dose comparison Buspar xanax Cialis generic viagra Cheaper viagra levivia cyalis Phentermine addiction Doxylamine Order viagra without prescription Viagra pills uk Comparison viagra cialis levitra Vicodin cod Lysodren Phentermine review Phenindione Alternative to viagra drug Viagra shelf life Purchase fioricet Phentermine a159 Phentermine eprescriptions Hydrocodone cough syrup M357 vicodin Compare generic viagra prices Compare levivia viagra Generic overnight viagra Hydrocodone drug test Tyropanoate Butriptyline Heroin Flavoxate Viagra 6 free sample Zyrtec Phentermine with free shipping Buy phentermine in the uk Repaglinide Lowest drug price for phentermine Viagra jokes Nifedipine Phentermine buy online Phentermine resin Viagra treatment migraine headache Betaxolol Book buy online order viagra Buying viagra on line Disulfiram Cialis new viagra Triamcinolone Phentermine faqs Caffeine Flagyl Non perscription generic viagra What is phentermine civ Tramadol drug Clomiphene Tramadol cash on delivery Natural alternative to viagra Demecarium Macrobid Molindone Buy Valium Phenytoin interaction with xanax Viagra advertisements Amphetamine Phentermine 15 mg Glipizide Viagra cream Bentyl Generic cialis uk Cyproheptadine Avelox Soma getting Chlorcyclizine Tramadol and drug tests Phentermine hcl 37.5 mg Phentermine ups delivery Losec How does phentermine work Cinnarizine Viagra buy in uk online Counterfeit viagra Granisetron Buy Soma Free phentermine prescriptions Phentermine success stories Wholesale phentermine Taking viagra or levivia as a booster for cialis Rizatriptan Amoxil Buspar Cialis compared to viagra Discount cialis Phentermine side effects Buy phentermine online prescription Phentermine overnight delivery no prescription Elidel Paxil with phentermine interactions Vicodin drug test Hydrocodone Albuterol Tramadol Fioricet order Ash of soma Buying viagra online uk Ambien medication Add link phentermine purchase Sell viagra online Soma pill Buy prescription tramadol without Xanax online no prescription Ansaid Cyclandelate Paregoric Phentermine sales online Xanax lethal dose Fiorinal Online xanax Is it safe to take prozac and phentermine Nutmeg Furosemide Xanax drug tests Timolol Compare cialis levitra Phentermine 37.5 mg diet pill Best buy phentermine Nystatin Xanax anxiety Cheap cialis tablets Demeclocycline Chloramphenicol Clopidogrel Aldactone Accupril Ambien sleeping pill Impotence treatment viagra Atrovent Alcohol hydrocodone Information on phentermine Womens viagra Advair How to discontinue the use of phentermine Imdur Hydroxychloroquine American express phentermine Phentermine cheapest price Cialis levivia viagra vs vs Diet pal pay phentermine pill Free prescription sample viagra Cheap phentermine overnight delivery Viagra without prescription Meridia weight loss pill Tramadol use in dogs Buy ambien Methylphenidate Morphine Cheap viagra india Viagra and blindness Fluorouracil Cheap online order viagra Viagra recreational use Generic money order viagra Cefadroxil Percocet Buy meridia online Mevacor Bleomycin Phentermine accepts cod Cyclosporine Viagra online order guide Ampicillin Buy viagra on line Xanax dose Buy viagra online get prescription Mexican pharmacies online+xanax Decamethonium Alternative herbal viagra Buy Tylenol Cheap ambien No overnight prescription xanax Cialis comparison levivia viagra Viagra cialis levitra Viagra online consultation Ativan xanax Paramethadione How quick can you lose weight with phentermine Oxacillin Cipro Viagra online ordering Phentermine success Ipratropium Strattera Hexachlorophene Cialis viagra levivia Why phentermine Viagrafix Soft tab viagra Xanax no prescription overnight delivery Cheapest tramadol available online Aricept How long does viagra last Effect viagra Hydrocodone vicodin Phentermine online consultation Senna Vicodin health Geodon Tetanus Zyban Diet pill phentermine Buy com lvivhost online viagra Argento soma Cefonicid Tramadol 377 Levoxyl Phentermine 37.5 in round white tablets no imprint code Hydrochlorothiazide Cheep phentermine with cod payments Miconazole Phentermine and birth defects Xanax dosages Alavert Levivia versus viagra Xanax overnight Restless leg syndrome phentermine Order xanax paying cod Adipex diet discount phentermine pill Phentermine vs adipex p Viagra picture Phentermine no prescription needed Cheapest phentermine Over the counter viagra Bayer Free shipping on phentermine diet pills Lowest prices for tramadol online Pink oval pill 17 xanax identification Canada cialis generic Trimethoprim What do xanax look like No fax payday loan buy tramadol Potassium Nicorette Pictures of xanax bars Tramadol side effects Viagra impotence pill Xanax photos Epo Diamox Phenylephrine Oxycontin Phentermine saturday delivery Coreg Catapres Xenical hgh phentermine quit smoking Ultram tramadol hci tablet Pictures of mylan xanax Cod online pharmacy phentermine sell Generic viagra india Loss phentermine story weight Order cheap phentermine Cheapest phentermine diet pill Viagra online cheap Melphalan Buy cialis viagra Soma drug Cialis vs viagra Best price phentermine Order ambien Buy tramadol Alprazolam xanax Cheapest viagra Hydrocodone m357 Viagra uk sales Buy soma Iothalamate

December 6, 2006

Raymond Ibrahim: What they capture, they keep. When they lose, they complain to the U.N.

A must read op-ed in the LA Times, by Raymond Ibrahim:

[..] when Muslims beat infidels, it’s just too bad for the latter; they must submit to their new overlords’ rules with all the attendant discrimination and humiliation mandated for non-Muslims. Yet when Islam is beaten, demands for apologies and concessions are expected from the infidel world at large.

[..] If some Muslims wish to wage eternal jihad until Islam dominates the globe, they are only being true to Islam and its doctrines as they understand it. However, in that case, where the world is divided into two warring camps, Islam and Infidelity — or, in Islamic terms, the Abode of Islam and the Abode of War — how can these Muslims expect any concessions from the international community? The natural conclusion of the view that “might makes right” is “to the victor go the spoils.”

[..] But perhaps Muslims cannot be blamed for expecting special treatment, as well as believing that jihad is righteous and decreed by the Almighty. The West constantly goes out of its way to confirm such convictions. By criticizing itself, apologizing and offering concessions — all things the Islamic world has yet to do — the West reaffirms that Islam has a privileged status in the world.

[..] Muslims’ zeal for their holy places and lands is not intrinsically blameworthy. Indeed, there’s something to be said about being passionate and protective of one’s own. Here the secular West — Christendom’s prodigal son and true usurper — can learn something from Islam. For whenever and wherever the West concedes ideologically, politically and especially spiritually, Islam will be sure to conquer. If might does not make right, zeal apparently does.

So anyone going demand an apology for court ordered Bible burning in Uzbekistan? Can we get a little outrage at Christians, including priests, beaten and their Bibles burned in Kyrzystan? Christian priests brutally tortured and murdered in Pakistan and Kurdistan? Christians not being allowed to repair their churches in Egypt or churches demolished in Pakistan and Malaysia or burned in Nigeria? Christian schoolgirls beheaded in Indonesia (their parents said they forgave the killers)? Any imams, muftis, sheikhs out there apologised for any of this yet?

Raymond Ibrahim, an assistant in the African and Middle Eastern Division of the Library of Congress, has a book coming out called “The Al Qaeda Reader” which will be published April 17th 2007. The book contains “translations of religious texts and propaganda”, tracing “the origins and evolution of Al Qaeda” and “revealing an ideology that calls for a relentless jihad against non-Muslim “infidels,” repudiates democracy in favor of Islamic law, stresses the importance of martyrdom, and mocks the notion of “moderate” Islam.”

You can find more great op-eds from him on Victor Davis Hanson’s site.

(h/t Snapshots)

del.icio.us:Raymond Ibrahim: What they capture, they keep. When they lose, they complain to the U.N. digg:Raymond Ibrahim: What they capture, they keep. When they lose, they complain to the U.N. blinklist:Raymond Ibrahim: What they capture, they keep. When they lose, they complain to the U.N. furl:Raymond Ibrahim: What they capture, they keep. When they lose, they complain to the U.N. reddit:Raymond Ibrahim: What they capture, they keep. When they lose, they complain to the U.N. Y!:Raymond Ibrahim: What they capture, they keep. When they lose, they complain to the U.N.
Permalink • Print • Comment

November 15, 2006

A countdown to war P2: The Caucasian tinderbox.

The Caucasus is a region where the memory of war is all too recent and its horrors all too familiar, yet despite that its return is seemingly all but inevitable again. For centuries located at the meeting point of three empires - the Russian/Soviet, the Iranian/Persian and the Turkish/Ottoman, the Caucasus been a battle ground where these empires fought each other and fought to subdue the ethnic Caucasian nations and tribes, while the Caucasians fought each other. The temporary stability enforced by the Soviet Union evaporated with it and the 90s saw a number of conflicts ignite or reignite in the region. As recently as a year or two ago it seemed that the Caucasus was again heading for a lasting stability, besides the ongoing, although hushed up, Chechen insurgency that is, as Westerm influence grew in Georgia, Armenia and Azerbaijan and Russia itself was still keeping up some appearance of embracing Western style democracy.

How much things have changed in a year.

Another war in the Caucasus is on the way. And not necessarily in the shape that a scan of current news headlines may bring to mind.

Russia reloads.

By default the suspicion for any destabilisation of the region first falls on Russia, the “re-emerging empire”, as the Georgian President Sakashvilli recently referred to it. So far its “re-emergence” has mostly been by non-military means, ie via its all but official foreign policy of energy blackmail. Re-enabling it’s military options however is evidently on the minds of Moscow’s policy makers too. Russia has increased its national defence budget from 140 billion rubles ($5.2 billion) in 2001, to 870 billion rubles ($32.4 billion) in 2007. Thats an increase of more than 6 times. What these numbers translate to in terms of strategic capabilities is of course another matter - how this money is spent is shrouded in secrecy, as tends to be the case in authoritarian regimes, and budget secrecy has the downside of massive built in inefficiency. (In light of which perhaps Putin should rethink his personal motto of “Get rich and keep quiet”. What is that about?) The Russian military consists of between 1.3 and 4 million people, depending on how you define “military” - an area where the Russians like to get creative, depending on the impression they seek to project - which suggests an expensive luxury.

Said Russian Deputy Prime Minister and Defense Minister Sergei Ivanov last month:

“When I came to the Defense Ministry, its budget was some 140 billion rubles. This was in 2001. The figure that has almost been agreed upon for 2007 is about 870 billion rubles. As they say, compare and feel the difference”

Georgian overconfidence.

One Caucasian nation that could really be “feeling the difference” is of course Georgia, incidentally the fastest-arming country in the world, which has two regions attempting to secede and join Russia - Abkhazia and South Ossetia. Georgia is making a nice profit from the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan (BTC) pipeline that went online in June, and is expected to produce about 1.5% of its national income. Much like increased oil revenue has allowed the Russians its military spending indulgences, Georgia has been using its newly acquired funds (recently offset by the Russian blockade) for a massive beefing up of its military, Jane’s reports:

Under Minister of Defence Irakli Okruashvili, Georgian militarisation is proceeding apace. Spending has risen from less than USD25 million in 2002 to an exceptional USD337 million in 2006; from 0.7 to 5 per cent of GDP. Maximum force strength has been increased and an army reserve of 100,000 trained civilians is being created. Significant stocks of armoured vehicles, artillery and attack helicopters have been procured. A major ‘NATO-standard’ base has been constructed close to Abkhazia and another is underway near South Ossetia.

It now seems that it is Georgia that has overplayed its hand with its recent posturing over the Russian spy scandal, while attempting to draw international attention to Russian encouragement of its separatist regions. Not only have the Russians come down hard on Georgia, international condemnation has also been falling on the Georgians for initially escalating the affair. Counting on Western support President Mikhail Saakashvili may be preparing for an attempt to regain control of the break away regions by force. The Russians on the other hand are drawing attention to the various new nations whose separatist movements the West has encouraged - most recently Montenegro, and most importantly in the near future, Kosovo - as examples of Western self-serving hypocrisy.

Burning for vengeance in the Land of Eternal Fire.

But of course the possibility of confict between Georgia and Russia is a surprise to noone right now. In fact there is another conflict in the Caucasus which seems far more certain.

Also benefitting nicely from the BTC pipeline, but lacking the media attention, is Georgia’s neighbour, Azerbaijan, the economy of which is expected to grow 18% as a result of the pipeline. Like Georgia it is spending much of its profits on arming itself. On October 18th Azerbaijan’s President Ilham Aliyev announced that Azerbaijan’s defense expenditures will rise to $1 billion in 2007. Thats compared to $300 million in 2005. The Azeris fought a war with Armenia after the parliament of its Nagorno-Karabakh region, which has an Armenian majority, voted to join Armenia back in 1988. The first Nagorno-Karabakh War ended in 1994, claiming about 35,000 lives. In that conflict Armenia’s military proved superior. Now Azerbaijan is getting busy attempting to correct its disatvantage. Armenia on the other hand, which has no oil to sell, had a defence budget of $160 million this year and their entire national budget in 2005 was $930.7 million, which is less than next year’s defence budget alone for the Azeris. The status of the Nagorno-Karabakh region remains disputed, with no country officially recognising its independence. Armenia and Azerbaijan remain at a stand off, technically still at war, however the regions outskirts are currently a site of daily skirmishes and sniper attacks which, together with landmines claim about a 100 lives a year. 2006 was seen as a window of opportunity for resolving the conflict with diplomacy, as neither nation had an election this year. The window is fast closing. Some progress has been made in negotiating the return of areas that Armenia occupied during the last war that were strategically important for the defence of Nagorno-Karabakh. But the real source of their disagreements - the status of Nagorno-Karabakh itself - is no closer to resolution than it was a decade ago.

An incident that reflects the depths of the animosity between the two nations occured in Budapest, Hungary, in 2004 at a training seminar which was part of the Partnership for Peace NATO-sponsored program. One early morning an Azerbaijani officer, Ramil Safarov, came into the bedroom where the Armenian Lieutenant Gurgen Markaryan was sleeping and hacked him to death with an axe. In response to the incident the human rights commissioner of Azerbaijan, Elmira Suleymanova, stated that “Safarov must become an example of patriotism for the Azerbaijani youth.” An Azeri political scientist, Zardusht Alizade, is also quoted as saying that Safarov “will be raised to the status of a national hero”. And Farida Askerova, Chairwoman of the Organization for the Liberation of Karabakh women’s board: “The young people ought to be ready for the holy war; every mother must raise a son to fight for the Motherland”.

azerbaijan
And in February of this year, the following from Iskander Gamidov of the opposition National Democratic Party of Azerbaijan:

“Maybe in a month, maybe in a year or two, but sooner or later war will be inevitable. We should prepare for it and prepare society,” This was said a roundtable meeting titled ‘Prospects for the Karabakh settlement by military means’.

In a recent development Arkady Gukasian, the President of Nagorno-Karabakh signed a decree on November 3rd to hold a referendum Dec. 10 regarding the draft of the Nagorno-Karabakh Constitution.

The big question is who the major regional and world powers will back in the conflict. The US is likely to do everything in its power to prevent a war. Firstly there are more Armenians in the US than in Armenia, making for a powerful lobby. Secondly the US has growing economic interests in Azerbaijan, due to energy investments. Azerbaijan has been growing into a regional energy hub, both as a source of oil and a post of transit from Caspian oil and gas from Central Asia. In addition Azerbijian is a potential, although reluctant ally against Iran. Also there are more Azeris in Iran than in Azerbijian, 17 million or 24% of Iran’s population in fact, something Iran is uneasy about. In any case Iran has been developing its ties with Armenia, in part to counter Turkish influence in Azerbaijan and in part to keep a lever against Baku. There is little scope for the US to take sides in any confict here - it wants the region stable. As does the EU, which is looking to diversify its energy sources away from Russia. If absolutely forced however the US would have to side with the Azeris. But Azeribaijan’s closest ally and firmest backer is Turkey, with many Azeri officers currently studying there. A Turkish trained and advised army fighting against Armenia adds another grim dimension to the developments (the official position of the Azeri government on the Armenian genocide, by the way, is one of outright denial). Moscow, although not hostile to Azerbaijan per se, is closely allied, through the CSTO, with Armenia, where it is has been aggressively buying up infrastructure and has as its ultimate goal control of the whole Caucasus.

caucasus

An overcrowded chessboard.

And this is far from the end of the the smoldering problems in the Caucasus. The trouble for the Russians is far from over in Chechnya and is perhaps only starting in surrounding regions like Dagestan, North Ossetia and Ingushetia, no matter how hard Moscow likes to pretend it has the situation there under control. And the trouble hasn’t even started yet for the various foreign companies that have been investing in Caspian oil and gas and building pipelines across the Caucasus going through to the Black Sea and Turkey. The Caspian Pipeline Consortium’s (CPC) pipeline is the only pipeline on Russian soil that is not owned and controlled by the Russians - something Moscow is intent on remedying. They are also far from happy about any pipes taking energy resources out of Central Asia via any other route they don’t control, ie across Russian territory. As American influence has weakened in the region the Russians are growing bolder in enforcing their desires on their neighbours - and energy has been been their favored lever to push. The BTC pipeline, which passes through Azerbaijan and Georgia (avoiding CSTO member Armenia) into Turkey, drags a host of Western interests directly into the line of Russian ire, although that was part of the reason it was installed in the first place - Western economic involvement, and thus influence, in the region was one of the objectives, not a side effect. In reality should war break out the de facto over-involvement may morph into a liability. Kazakhstan also has a significant stake on oil sent through the BTC and another pipeline in a similar direction is likely in a couple of years for their massive Kashagan field in the north of the Caspian Sea. And lets not forget the Iranians. It was only in the 19th century that parts of the Caucasus, particularly in what is now Azerbaijan, were part of their empire, before the Czarist Russia made it a part of theirs. Iranian influence amongst the Shia of Azerbaijan has been increasing, as it has among all the Shia populations in the Middle East. Azeri President Ilham Aliyev has recently spoken out in support of the Iranians’ right to nuclear power development. At the same time Armenia’s relationship with Iran has also been warming. Armenia is reliant on Russia and Iran for its energy and has Russian military bases on its territory. As already mentioned, it is a member of the Russian led Collective Security Treaty Organization.

Implications and opportunities for the West.

Should another war over Nagorno-Karabagh prove imminent a number of opportunities may present themselves to the West in dealing its current problem numero uno, Iran:

1. Challenging the perception in the Muslim world that Iran is the new champion of Islam by hammering the fact that it is supporting (Christian) Armenia against (mostly Shia) Muslim Azerbaijan, thus shattering the image Tehran is trying to create as the global champion of Islam against the Zionist and Christian Crusaders. Actually Azerbaijan was briefly the world’s first Muslim republic between 1918 and 1920, before the Soviets took control, seeking access to Baku’s oil. Ironically Armenia claims to be the world’s first Christian state. Azerbaijan is a perfect candidate for a Western ally in the Muslim world. It remains largely secular, unafflicted by extremism (except a small but growing Salafist movement amongst Sunnis near the Dagestan border) and is even a prime example of religious tolerance. Baku has the largest Jewish synagogue in Europe, built there in 2003 and unlike Iran, Azerbaijan is proud of its Zoroastrian roots - the name Azerbaijan means Land of The Eternal Fire, a place where Zoroastrian fire temples flourished for thousands of years. In fact their main holiday is Novruz, from the Zoroastrian tradition.

2. Fermenting unrest in Northern Iran by turning the focus of Azeri nationalism towards South Azerbaijan - otherwise known is northwestern Iran. As much as the US wants the Caucasus stable (and Caspian oil flowing westward) if that is not achievable than the it is in its interest to have Iran destabilised and the Iranians know it. A possibility to explore is the brokering of a deal which would allow Nagorno-Karabagh independence in return for full US support for Azeri interests in Iran, perhaps even floating the idea of the formation of a Greater Azerbaijan. Iran should be as worried about the Azeri state as Turkey is about an independent Kurdistan. If the answer to Iraq is Tehran, could this be an opportunity to give them a riddle of their own?
The situation in Georgia is another reason for the Azebaijan to seek closer ties with the US - Russia is ultimately seeking regime change in Tbilisi. Should Georgia turn into a Russian outpost, like Armenia, it will next turn its focus on Azerbaijan, which would then be effectively cut off from the West. And Nagorno Karabakh would give it the perfect pretext to do so aggresively. Baku has been careful not to appear to be too close to any of the three courting powers. Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev has stated for example that Azerbaijan would never become a staging ground for a US attack on Iran, despite rumours to the contrary and current negotiations with the US about renovating an Azeri air base as a refueling station for NATO planes traveling to Afghanistan. He also declined a invitation from Moscow to join a Russian led “counterterrorism” navy group on the Caspian, CASFOR, but did stop by Moscow last week for a chat with Putin ahead of Azerbaijan’s upcoming negotiations with Gazprom, straight after visitting Brussels and signing an energy agreement with the European Union. And the Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad met Aliyev in Baku on May 4th with the Iranians even announcing they are studying the possibility of transporting Iranian oil via the BTC pipeline. But Baku’s oil wealth is pegged to Western interests. Although fear of Iranian wrath from the south is a strong motivator in Baku, the Azeris know most of their prospects for growth lie eastward, with their friends in Turkey, in the EU, which is keen for Azeri gas, even in Israel, which gets 20% of its oil from Azerbaijan. This understanding should be further reinforced should Moscow’s stance towards Baku grow pushy or threatening.

3. Driving a wedge between Russia and Iran. Both are none too happy about Caspian oil flowing westward to Turkey, via Azerbaijan and Georgia, rather than north through Russia or south through Iran. Their clash of both economic and political interests here can be exploited. There is also a conflict of interest in Armenia. For example when the Iranians built a gas pipeline through Armenia Moscow demanded its diameter be limited to 700 millimeters, instead of the 1,420 millimeters in the original design, precluding the possibility of Iranian gas transitting to Georgia (or further to the Ukraine) via that line. Armenia promptly agreed. Russian state gas monopoly Gazprom pretty much owns Armenia’s gas distribution system. Another possible point of contention is Iran’s recent agreement with Georgia to supply it with energy. The EU is considering Iran as an option towards diversification away from overdependence on Russian gas. Yet another sign of possible tensions between Russia and Iran is the postponement last week of the Iranian Foreign Minister’s visit to Moscow, reportedly because of Iranian annoyance that the Russians said they may postpone the construction of Iran’s Bushehr nuclear reactor. Yet despite all these conflicts of interest Moscow and Tehran appear tentatively in the process of becoming energy partners - a partnership in which Russia will no doubt come out dominant. Russia partners with Iran to counterbalance Western influence in their respective peripheries and because Iran keeps the US busy while Russia pursues its own political goals unhindered.

Currently there is talk in the US of making deals with Iran over Iraq. But Iran no longer backed by Russia would lose much of its clout so the saner option of negotiating with Russia should be explored. Besides support for Nagorno Karabkh and assurance of keeping Tehran’s influence out of the Caucasus and Central Asia perhaps Russian involvement in the development of the Kashagan oil field, estimated to be the world’s fourth largest, in the north of the Caspian Sea could be placed on the table.

Also see update, 11/16/06.

del.icio.us:A countdown to war P2: The Caucasian tinderbox. digg:A countdown to war P2: The Caucasian tinderbox. blinklist:A countdown to war P2: The Caucasian tinderbox. furl:A countdown to war P2: The Caucasian tinderbox. reddit:A countdown to war P2: The Caucasian tinderbox. Y!:A countdown to war P2: The Caucasian tinderbox.
Permalink • Print • Comment

August 23, 2006

Spy stories: The Count, the Prince and the Joker.

Everyone loves a good spy story, a daring conspiracy, a glimpse of the invisible hands that shape the world, the steadfast men of ideas that direct history from the shadows, manipulating events on the world stage from behind a curtain of intrigue.

One such “man of ideas”, a ruthless wheeler and dealer and a man who certainly left his mark on history, in ways both overt and covert, was the French spychief Count Alexandre de Marenches. The Count was the longest serving head of the Service de Documentation Extérieure et de Contre-Espionnage (SDECE, France’s version of the CIA), serving as its director from 1970 through to 1981. Below are a couple of tales from Count de Marenches’ large arsenal. But first a little more about the man and his ideas.

In 1992 the Count co-authored with NY Times’ Paris correspondent David A. Andelman, “The Fourth World War: Diplomacy and Espionage in the Age of Terrorism”, a book that has since revealed itself to be ahead of its time, but back in 1992 was snubbed by reviewers for making unfounded claims from an “extremist” viewpoint. The book is perhaps the first instance of the suggestion that the next World War would be against international terrorism and rogue states. In it the Count called for the establishment of a “Decent People’s Club” of countries that would band together to crush the new slippery bad guys. Count de Marenches’ name for this new conflict was the politically incorrect “South-North War”.

Allister Heath wrote of Count de Marenches and his book last week:

When it came to fighting terrorists, Count Alexandre de Marenches, the legendary former head of France’s intelligence services, knew what he was talking about. In a prescient book published just after the end of the Cold War, he was the first to warn that a fourth world war had already begun — a war waged by ‘small, highly deadly units of terrorists’ with ‘the very real prospect of ending civilisation, at least Western civilisation, as we know it’. A